Best Organic K-Cups: A Quick Guide on What to Choose

Back in the day, preparing coffee is a time-consuming and complicated task. Today, it has become a lot easier, especially with the introduction of innovative coffeemakers, including the one from Keurig. With the latter, you can use revolutionary K-cups to prepare your coffee quickly and without guesswork, guaranteeing consistent and delicious taste.

If you are thinking of buying K-cups, we have you covered in the rest of this guide. This post, however, will be focused on those that are organic. We will go through five of the top picks that are available on the market and some of the things that make them exceptional. We’ll also give you a quick look at some of the essential factors that you have to consider.

#1. San Francisco Bay OneCup Organic Rainforest Blend

One of the many things to love in this coffee is the fact that it is made with the use of beans that have been carefully-selected from all over the world. To be specific, these beans are from Indonesia, Guatemala, Mexico, and Colombia.

More than being organic, this is also a low-acid coffee. If you often experience stomach discomfort after drinking too much coffee, such is one thing that can be avoided if you choose this one.

It is made using 100% Arabica coffee beans. These are the beans that are grown in high altitude, which is one of the reasons why it has a full-bodied taste. To balance the bitterness, it also has citrusy notes.

It is also a good thing that it can be used not only with Keurig brewers, but also with other popular brands, such as Bunn, Cuisinart, and iCoffee.


Has low acid
Compatible with multiple brewers

Cups can be prone to exploding
Some people might find it a bit bitter
Also Read: Best Keurig Coffee Makers – Reviews and Buying Guide

#2. Caza Trail Coffee – Organic Extra Bold Medium Roast

Selected coffee beans from the regions of Indonesia and Latin America have been blended to produce this organic coffee. It has the perfect balance of being bold and smooth. There is moderate acidity in this coffee.

One thing that the company takes pride in is the fact that they have a team of expert coffee tasters. They are the ones making sure that quality is never overlooked throughout the process of production.

More than being organic, this coffee is also Kosher, USDA, and Fair Trade certified.


Has an affordable price
Does not clog coffeemakers

Some find the taste to be weak
Can have a burnt aftertaste

#3. Green Mountain Coffee Newman’s Special Blend

The unique flavor of this coffee is made possible with the use of premium beans from two of the most popular coffee-growing regions in the world – Central America and Indonesia. It is rich and robust. Since it is a medium roast, this is perfect for those who would like to be in between light and dark roasts.

It is not only an organic coffee, but it is also Fair Trade-certified. This means that the coffee is made in such a manner that the needs of the farmers are prioritized. The company is responsible enough to make sure that the farmers are compensated fairly and they also do what it takes to give back to the community.

Lastly, the cups have a no-mess design, which will make it free from the penetration of air, heat, light, moisture, and other things that could have a negative impact on its overall quality.


Full-bodied blend
Has a smooth taste

Some cups can be loose
Taste is weak for some
Also Read: Best Grind and Brew Coffee Makers: Reviews & Complete Buying Guide

#4. Organic Coffee K-cups Variety Pack

If you are the type of person who is into variety, this is one of the options that you might want to consider. It is not as popular as those that have been mentioned above, but you can expect exciting flavors to tickle your taste buds.

The K-cups in this pack are all organic, but they are from different brands and have random flavors. Some that are included in the set include Green Mountain Organic Sumatra Aceh, Marley Coffee One Love, Caza Trail Extra Bold Medium Roast, and First Colony Organic Espresso Roast.

Even if this is a variety pack, expect that all that are included in the package are made from 100% Arabica coffee beans. Not all of them, however, are Fair Trade Certified.


Different flavors in one pack
Affordable price

Minimal user reviews are available online
Flavor can be inconsistent

#5. Real Good Coffee – USDA Certified Organic Dark Roast

If you want a coffee that is good for you and for the environment, this is the one that you should choose. These organic coffee pods are made from 100% recyclable materials, which means that you won’t be doing any harm to the environment.

In terms of flavor, it has an exotic and exciting taste. The beans are from Sumatra, a popular coffee region in South Asia. It has a full-body without too much bitterness.

To be specific, the flavor has roast notes and will be reminiscent of lemon, cedar, and bell pepper.


Good for the planet
Consistently great flavor

Pods can smell like soap
Coffee can have sludge from the grounds
Also Read: Best Affordable and Durable Nespresso Coffee Machine

Essential Factors to Consider

Before I give you a quick review of some of the top products to include on your list, here are some of the most important things that you have to take into account:

Compatibility: Take the time to look at the brewer that you have, specifically its brand and model. When shopping for coffee cups, make sure that they are compatible with your viewer. Otherwise, your money will be put to waste.
Origin: The region in which the beans used in the K-cups are grown is an important consideration because it will greatly affect the flavor and aroma. Choose those that are from popular regions to be confident of its taste.
Flavor: Aside from the origin of the beans, there are other ingredients that the manufacturer can add to alter the flavor of your coffee. Do you like it sweet or bitter? Do you want it mild or robust? Think about these things when deciding on the flavor.
Certifications: Look for the sign that says the coffee is certified to be organic. Also, Fair Trade Certification is a good thing as it means that the coffee is manufactured while paying attention to the needs of the local farming community. If it is Kosher certified, on the other hand, it means that it complies with the Jewish religious dietary laws.


If you like organic coffee, keep an eye on the K-cups that have been mentioned above. They have exciting flavor and aroma that will impress even sophisticated caffeine lovers.

With these coffee cups, it will be easy to enjoy your cup of Joe. There is no need to worry about how to make a consistently perfect coffee!

Scroll to Top